Its getting WAAAAAAAAAAAYYYYYYYYYYYYY too complicated. (unecessarily I might add)

Your correct in that you cannot remove subjectivity, but you should try and limit it. If you take one suit of armor and put it infront of 5 GMs the call should be the same 4/5 times, if not 5/5. If its 2/5 or 3/5 then theres a problem. We currently have that problem. I personally am against stacking...

Sigh. Somebody shoot me. I agree with Ried again.

I'm right, the Books wrong.

We'll have to get this one in a FAQ asap.


You can 'Unlearn' ANY skill with the exception of your Basic level in your Chosen Path.

As much as I'd hate to see Scotts face any more then possible..

That would make a great cover for the new 'fancy' rulebook.

Again, Im with Ried.

Man this is getting scary.

That picture of Kels is freekin Awesome!!

I wanted to ask on this myself, Why it got a work over in the first place? Originally "Shatter" meant 'Shatter'. If I hit a weapon its destroyed. If I hit a sheild its destroyed. If I hit Armor its destroyed. Simple. This is an ULTRA rare NPC only call. Its not going to be used all the time.

I have to agree that REALLY GOOD costuming facial coverage should be taken into account.

In the scenarios she mentioned he was Rogue (master) Path, but had also learned additional Warrior Path skills.

To unlearn the Warrior skills, or to reduce his Rogue level, would be done as normally.

He could never unlearn beyond Basic Rogue.

Better?

Yes, the real answer is Yes. (man that felt redundant)

I was simply pointing out that I was mistaken in my thought that we ALL made the change, when it only happened in my head.

Ok, your mostly right, except.... Your 'primary discipline' is which ever discipine you have the most levels in. ~ If you have lvl 1 Assasin & lvl 1 Archer then Assasin is your primary. If you buy lvl 2 Archer, Archer becomes your primary as it is you highest total levels of Dicipline skills. ~ ...

Part of the problem was based on a misconception. I wanted helms removed from 'Armor totals' and thought they were... but no one else thought that apparently.
When all is said and done I think it might get cleaned up in explaination, but not much will actually change.

If we remove Armor I will burn this place to the ground!! I will leave not a scorched stone to be remembered by your children and your childrens children!! I will salt the earth!
I will...... I will...

I will Whine relentlesly and Stomp my feet.

For the record (and I cant believe Im saying this) but for the most part I agree with Reid. Nebulousness leads to inconsistency. Im not saying every detail must appear in the Rulebook, just that it should be somewhere and it should be solid. As for Nelkie and the hats, Mickey; Light fake Cloth Helm;...